Mr. Daisey and the Apple Factory - A Different View
Mr. Daisey definitely portrays the misery of the factory
workers in Shenzhen, China, that it would be hard not to be moved and there is no doubt that his accounts are
factual to a degree. The question arises as to what can be done, and does the
Western world have the right to force China to conform to their standards.
Americans as do most human beings have this inborn believe that the way they do
this is the right way and no one else is doing it right. With this in mind, it
would be beneficial to look at the evolution
of Democracy and Capitalism.
It was not that far in the past at the beginning of the industrial
revelation , that the USA did not have unions and the factories employed children
sometimes younger than Mr. Daisey mentioned. Conditions were much worse than
Mr. Daisey mentioned in his presentation, with children working in underground
coal mines with safety almost non-existing. The US government opposed unions at
first linking them with communism
and Marxist. There were bloody
and sometimes fatal encounters with the unions by the police. Teamsters used to
sit up on hills shooting truck drivers in the steel mill as they went from
building to building, and others perched on over passes shooting non-union
truckers. Should Americans go over to China and start pushing non-government
unions and more than likely a bloodshed. Or should the Chinese be left alone
for the own evolution to take place. It has been said that "Before you
condemn another first look in the mirror". Americans do not have a very
pretty history when they look in their mirror. True things are much better
today than the past so the tendency is to treat China as a child and try to
make things better, but as a child rarely hears the parents advice and have to
learn things for themselves so will China have to learn for herself.
Cultural interference is possibly the number one reason so
many countries around the world hate Americans. Even with in the USA the
results of cultural interference can be seen. Most presently the cultures of
Alaska have suffered this interference, with alcoholism, suicides,
dislocations, and more. Alaska natives have a saying, "The only good thing
the white man has brought to Alaska was the common language". The common
consensus in America is the only good government is Democracy, and the only
good money system is capitalism. However there are monarchs that have better
lives than US citizen as a whole. True they are the exception but it shows the
falsify of the thinking.
It would be great if it were possible to make everything in
China right and there was no greed in the world, and the world was filled with
love, love, love! Ok wake up and smell the menure the world stinks, but before
trying to clean up the neighbors yard shuvel the menure out of yours.
No comments:
Post a Comment