Everything
comes from China. Well not literally everything but it is easy to think so. Child
labor and poor working conditions is prevalent in much of the Chinese
industrial workplaces in which our products are assembled. It was interesting
to ponder the idea that my computer and my phone were both manufactured in a
similar factory mentioned by Mr. Daisy. Visualizing America as a sole producer of
computer products is a difficult thought. American labor is expensive and not
as abundant as Chinese labor where there are millions of working hands.
American companies like Apple are capable of making more money with inexpensive
labor costs. As consumers we spend relatively less compared to what it would
cost to manufacture the product in America.
I found it
fascinating that Mr. Daisy was able to talk to so many workers and hear all
their experiences. The differential in American and and Chinese work facilities
is shocking. Even though China is primarily socialist, their communist colors
really show in their factories. An American really can’t fathom what it would
be like to get black listed in China. Middle classed Chinese union members
could potentially be prosecuted and black listed, inevitably making it so that
they can no longer work and make a living. What’s even more amazing is that
some Chinese factories like Foxconn have facility personnel equivalent to the
population of a city.
Mike Daisy
didn’t shine much of a positive perspective on the Chinese work condition. He
made it evident that there were injuries and suicides but he didn’t mention the
demand for work. Imagine applying for a job when there are twenty or more
people applying for the same job. In most cases workers are expendable.
Therefore it is crucial for people to put up with the working conditions or
have no conditions to go along with the work because they have no job. Sadly
work is usually the only option. Another thing to consider is maybe the working
conditions don’t actually seem that bad to the workers as they seem to us
through our interpretation of Mikes recording. These foreign Multi-million
dollar corporations having us Americans as popular consumers is what’s creating
jobs and expanding the Chinese blade runner empire.
Mr. Daisy’s
approach to his opinion of apple technology was different, but it was somewhat effective
information nonetheless. Much of his statements are unsupported, all Michael
really has is a story. Honestly I love my apple products, and many other
foreign products that were probably made in a sweatshop. The fact of the matter
is I won’t dis-continue using something if it was made by hand in an
undeveloped country under some low lighting. Even though this work is
distasteful, somebody has to do it to keep the consumer and the producer in
order. Some places have even worse working conditions. Imagine if Mr. Daisy was
infatuated with Diamonds and he decided to wander over to Africa to learn where
they came from.
I completely disagree with your reaction to the working conditions in Chinese factories. Respectfully of course. I agree that we as Americans have been socially integrated to expect better condiotions for ourselves and that the Chinese culture is prodominatly taught and conditioned to do what it takes to feed their families. To work hard and play less. That said however,it does not make it ok to treat people like expedable parts of a machine. I dont believe somebody HAS to do it. I actually beleive that we as human beings should REFUSE to manufacture products for a company that treats us like less than what we are. I dont believe money, products, and profit should be over human rights. I must agree that to survive, we as Americans will have to use products manufactured in such conditions. That doesnt mean I believe someone has to do it. I wish someone with some fire behind them would stand up and change such things in the world.
ReplyDeleteHello, "Unknown"! I would really like to know who you are so I can give you credit for your work. If you don't mind just signing your posts with your initials or your name, that would be sufficient. Thanks!
ReplyDelete